From Leon’s notebook · Personal experience
Diversity Statement

In a meeting earlier today, while working on a job description for a Chief Information Officer, the topic of a diversity statement came up. This will be a true rant against the whole concept of diversity statements.
The idea is that somebody can put their beliefs about diversity on a piece of paper and convince me they mean it. If a beautifully written statement could do that, I would probably have a heart attack. I want to see what the person does.
A belief in diversity shows itself through an individual’s actions, year after year. I am not just talking about everyday actions. I am talking about what comes out when people are under pressure or in an uncomfortable situation, such as when your daughter comes home with a boyfriend of another race, or when she comes home with her girlfriend. At those points in life, you can learn how accepting you really are. It is about the ability to stop, think, and consider the ramifications of your thoughts and words, rather than simply saying the first thing that comes to mind.
One of my major disagreements with the diversity statement is that many individuals do not truly grasp the concept of diversity. I am a Black man, born in the early 1960s in New York City. I grew up in different low-income areas throughout New York and New Jersey until I was about 13.
In seventh grade, I attended William J. Hart Middle School in East Orange, New Jersey. As I remember it, the population was about 90 percent Black and 9 percent Hispanic. In eighth grade, I switched to Maplewood Middle School in Maplewood, New Jersey, where I remember the population as about 95 percent White, 3 percent Black, and other backgrounds making up the rest.
I spent the next five years in an area mostly populated by Italian and Jewish people. I attended Western Carolina University in Cullowhee, North Carolina, where, as I recall, the population was about 96 percent White and 2.5 percent Black, with other backgrounds making up the rest. I spent my summers in New York City’s Johnson projects, for those of you who know them.
I believe we should always hire the most qualified candidate and that organizations should be flexible enough to accommodate cultural differences. Yet people always seem to talk about diversity with serious caveats about hiring somebody who fits the institutional culture.
To me, that logic is a contradiction. For example, if you do not have an appreciation for government cheese and lunches served at the elementary school during the summer, you and I may not come from the same culture. I might even wonder if we came from the same planet. But that should never affect my decision about hiring you for a job. The decision should be based on your qualifications to do the work.
At meetings, I keep hearing the same argument: a person must fit the culture of the organization to ensure a smooth transition. It always seems to come from somebody who already fits that culture and can write a beautiful diversity statement full of flowery words.
My position is simple: get rid of the diversity statement and judge people by their actions over time. Hire the most qualified person for the job, rather than the person who makes everybody comfortable with the institution’s existing culture. If we did that, what would we need the statement for?