From Leon’s notebook · Personal experience
The Never-Ending Battle Between Students with Disabilities and College Professors

Earlier today, I read ‘A Reader Comments on Student Accommodations,’ a piece by George Leef discussing comments from Duke University professor John Staddon. It brought me back to a frustration I have had for a long time.
After more than 25 years of research into disabilities such as dyslexia, it amazes me that students still encounter college professors who resist basic accommodations. Some invoke academic freedom when asked to honor an accommodation, no matter how well documented the student’s need may be. Others argue that accommodations are unfair to the rest of the class.
Then comes tenure. From what I have seen, administrators can find it difficult to get a tenured professor to follow the institution’s accommodation requirements. College and university leaders need to address that problem, even when faculty senates and other powerful parts of the institution push back.
Common courtesy and basic decency should make the goal clear. If a student needs additional time on a test, a reader, or a transcriber, an educator should want an accurate picture of that student’s knowledge. How well does the student understand the subject? That ought to matter more than whether the student can reproduce information exactly as the professor prefers.
Unfortunately, these conflicts can lead presidents and chancellors into lawsuits and prolonged battles with faculty and the organizations that represent them. In those battles, the university’s mission to educate the next generation can get lost.
When a professor uses academic freedom and tenure as a shield against a student’s documented needs, I have to ask: At what point did the professor’s ego become more important than the student’s education?